A pay rise should be compared using the change in take-home pay, not only the new headline salary. Income Tax, employee National Insurance, pension contributions and any student-loan deduction can all change at the same time.
That does not mean a higher tax band makes you worse off. It means the extra salary and the extra amount reaching your bank account are different figures.
What to know first
UK Income Tax is progressive. Moving into a higher band does not apply the higher rate to your entire salary. It applies that rate to the part of taxable income falling inside the higher band.
For 2026/27, the standard Personal Allowance is £12,570. It reduces by £1 for every £2 of adjusted net income over £100,000. HMRC's current Income Tax rates and allowances set out the bands and explain that Scotland has different rates and bands for employment income.
Employee National Insurance is another separate deduction. For most employees in 2026/27, the main rate is 8% on monthly earnings from £1,048 to £4,189 and 2% above £4,189, according to the National Insurance guidance.
Step-by-step comparison
1. Record the complete current package
Use your gross salary, pension contribution and pension method, tax region, student-loan plan and any other regular payroll deductions. A comparison using salary alone can miss an important difference.
2. Calculate current annual and monthly take-home pay
Use the Take-Home Pay Calculator to create a baseline. Record both the annual result and the monthly figure, because a seemingly large annual increase can feel much smaller once divided across twelve months.
3. Enter the proposed salary without changing other assumptions
This isolates the effect of the pay rise. Compare:
- additional gross pay per year;
- additional take-home pay per year;
- additional take-home pay per month;
- the change in pension contribution;
- the change in student-loan repayment, if applicable.
4. Add costs caused by accepting the role
A promotion or new job may introduce commuting, childcare, professional clothing, parking, meals or a relocation. These do not appear on a payslip, but they affect whether the offer improves the household budget.
5. Compare benefits as well as cash
Employer pension contributions, bonuses, private medical cover, annual leave, flexible working and working hours can change the value of the offer. Keep uncertain bonuses separate from guaranteed salary.
Student loans can change the marginal result
For 2026/27, repayment thresholds differ by loan plan. The official repayment guidance lists annual thresholds of £26,900 for Plan 1, £29,385 for Plan 2, £33,795 for Plan 4, £25,000 for Plan 5 and £21,000 for a Postgraduate Loan.
Plans 1, 2, 4 and 5 deduct 9% of earnings over their relevant threshold. Postgraduate Loans deduct 6% over their threshold. Someone with more than one applicable loan type can have more than one deduction, so select the correct plan rather than using a generic percentage.
An illustrative way to frame the decision
Suppose an offer raises gross salary by £10,000. Do not assume either that the whole £10,000 reaches the bank or that one universal percentage applies.
Instead, calculate the two complete payroll outcomes and subtract:
new annual take-home pay − current annual take-home pay = annual take-home increase
Then divide the annual take-home increase by 12 for a monthly planning figure. Payroll calculations can vary slightly by pay period, tax code and rounding, so use the result as an estimate and check an actual payslip when available.
Common mistakes
- Applying the higher tax rate to the whole salary rather than the relevant slice.
- Comparing a monthly increase with annual commuting or childcare costs.
- Forgetting that percentage pension contributions can rise with salary.
- Selecting the wrong student-loan plan.
- Treating a discretionary bonus as guaranteed income.
- Ignoring the Personal Allowance taper above £100,000.
What to do next
Run the current salary and proposed salary through the same calculator assumptions. Then put the monthly difference—not the headline annual rise—into the Monthly Reality Check alongside any new work-related costs.
That produces a more useful question for a negotiation: not merely “How large is the raise?”, but “How much better off will this leave me each month?”
Information checked on 17 September 2026. Tax and payroll figures apply to the 2026/27 tax year. Scottish employment-income tax bands differ from those in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. Results are estimates, not individual tax or financial advice.